Descriptive Profiles for Sets of Alternatives in Multiple Criteria Decision Aid

International audienceIn the context of Multiple Criteria Decision Aid, a decision-maker may be faced at any time with the task of analyzing one or several sets of alternatives, irrespective of the decision he is about to make. As in this case the alternatives may express contrasting gains and losses on the criteria on which they are evaluated, and while the sets that are presented to the decision-maker may potentially be large, the task of analysing them becomes a difficult one. Therefore the need to reduce these sets to a more concise representation is very important. Classically, profiles that describe sets of alternatives may be found in the context of the sorting problem, however they are either given beforehand by the decision-maker or determined from a set of assignment examples. We would therefore like to extend such profiles, as well as propose new ones, in order to characterize any set of alternatives. For each of them, we present several approaches for extracting them, which we then compare with respect to their performance

Development and evaluation of an accelerometry system based on inverted pendulum to measure and analyze human balance

An accelerometry system was developed based on the inverted pendulum model and its effectiveness to measure the body's sway path and sway angle was verified in healthy adult volunteers. Sway path represents the body’s movement from its center of mass position projected to the ground surface while sway angle represents the body's orientation from the vertical. Mathematical models were developed to determine the sway displacement and sway angle from the accelerometry system. The resulting values were compared with the manual measurements obtained from a plumb bob based setup and found to correlate closely. Using the developed system, measures that analyzed the contribution of the visual, somatosensory and vestibular systems to balance were obtained. It was found that the accelerometry system followed the principle of motion of an inverted pendulum and provided information that can assist in better understanding of balance and thus it may assist clinicians in diagnosing balance dysfunctions

Electre Methods: Main Features and Recent Developments

We present main characteristics of Electre family methods, designed for multiple criteria decision aiding. These methods use as a preference model an outranking relation in the set of actions - it is constructed in result of concordance and non-discordance tests involving a specific input preference information. After a brief description of the constructivist conception in which the Electre methods are inserted, we present the main features of these methods. We discuss such characteristic features as: the possibility of taking into account positive and negative reasons in the modeling of preferences, without any need for recoding the data; using of thresholds for taking into account the imperfect knowledge of data; the absence of systematic compensation between "gains" and "losses". The main weaknesses are also presented. Then, some aspects related to new developments are outlined. These are related to some new methodological developments, new procedures, axiomatic analysis, software tools, and several other aspects. The paper ends with conclusions

The epidemiology of mild cognitive impairment (MCI) and Alzheimer’s disease (AD) in community-living seniors: protocol of the MemoVie cohort study, Luxembourg

BACKGROUND: Cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease (AD) are increasingly considered a major public health problem. The MemoVie cohort study aims to investigate the living conditions or risk factors under which the normal cognitive capacities of the senior population in Luxembourg (≥ 65 year-old) evolve (1) to mild cognitive impairment (MCI) – transitory non-clinical stage – and (2) to AD. Identifying MCI and AD predictors undeniably constitutes a challenge in public health in that it would allow interventions which could protect or delay the occurrence of cognitive disorders in elderly people. In addition, the MemoVie study sets out to generate hitherto unavailable data, and a comprehensive view of the elderly population in the country. METHODS/DESIGN: The study has been designed with a view to highlighting the prevalence in Luxembourg of MCI and AD in the first step of the survey, conducted among participants selected from a random sample of the general population. A prospective cohort is consequently set up in the second step, and appropriate follow-up of the non-demented participants allows improving the knowledge of the preclinical stage of MCI. Case-control designs are used for cross-sectional or retrospective comparisons between outcomes and biological or clinical factors. To ensure maximal reliability of the information collected, we decided to opt for structured face to face interviews. Besides health status, medical and family history, demographic and socio-cultural information are explored, as well as education, habitat network, social behavior, leisure and physical activities. As multilingualism is expected to challenge the cognitive alterations associated with pathological ageing, it is additionally investigated. Data relative to motor function, including balance, walk, limits of stability, history of falls and accidents are further detailed. Finally, biological examinations, including ApoE genetic polymorphism are carried out. In addition to standard blood parameters, the lipid status of the participants is subsequently determined from the fatty acid profiles in their red blood cells. The study obtained the legal and ethical authorizations. DISCUSSION: By means of the multidisciplinary MemoVie study, new insights into the onset of cognitive impairment during aging should be put forward, much to the benefit of intervention strategies as a whole

Age at onset as stratifier in idiopathic Parkinson’s disease – effect of ageing and polygenic risk score on clinical phenotypes

Several phenotypic differences observed in Parkinson’s disease (PD) patients have been linked to age at onset (AAO). We endeavoured to find out whether these differences are due to the ageing process itself by using a combined dataset of idiopathic PD (n = 430) and healthy controls (HC; n = 556) excluding carriers of known PD-linked genetic mutations in both groups. We found several significant effects of AAO on motor and non-motor symptoms in PD, but when comparing the effects of age on these symptoms with HC (using age at assessment, AAA), only positive associations of AAA with burden of motor symptoms and cognitive impairment were significantly different between PD vs HC. Furthermore, we explored a potential effect of polygenic risk score (PRS) on clinical phenotype and identified a significant inverse correlation of AAO and PRS in PD. No significant association between PRS and severity of clinical symptoms was found. We conclude that the observed non-motor phenotypic differences in PD based on AAO are largely driven by the ageing process itself and not by a specific profile of neurodegeneration linked to AAO in the idiopathic PD patients

On boosting Kohler's ranking-by-choosing rule with a quantiles preordering

Abstract Several ranking methods, like Tideman's ranked pairs, progressive Rubis best choices or Kohler's rule, have been proposed for ranking decision actions with multiple incommensurable performance criteria. Of these, Kohler's rule is by far the fastest ranking heuristic, yet also the less satisfactory in terms of ordinal correlation with a corresponding pairwise outranking relation. We show that preordering the decision actions to be ranked along quantiles, and then locally applying Kohler's rule on each equivalence class, greatly enhances this correlation without adding any essential algorithmic complexity. The combination of both, hence, becomes efficient for tackling large scale multiple criteria ranking problems. Keywords: Multiple criteria ranking, Kohler's ranking-by-choosing rule, Outranking approach, Quantiles sorting Aggregating multiple incommensurable criteria when following a bipolarly valued outranking approach leads to a reflexive and weakly complete binary preference relation which is reflexive and which satisfies the coduality principle An efficient heuristic TAS-closure, in terms of computational complexity, is given by Kohler's ranking-by-choosing rule When comparing now Kohler's ranking-by-choosing rule with more complex heuristic TAS-closures, like the progressive Rubis best choice extractio